Creditor lawsuits

Posted by Kevin Ryan | Sep 05, 2017 | 0 Comments

In most cases, a debt runs through a few general levels of collection. The first phase of collection usually involves the creditor making a direct effort to collect the debt.  Phone calls, written correspondence, additional interest and penalties added to the bill are the most common means of pressure applied directly by a creditor.  A creditor can take reasonable steps to contact you by phone or in writing without having to comply with the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.  

Once a creditor has made a direct effort to collect on an account for what is usually 90 to 120 days, the account will be referred to a third party collection firm.  A collection firm is usually not a group of attorneys, but rather a company that focuses on pressuring you, the debtor, by legal means into paying the debt.  This can involve frequent telephone calls and written correspondence. The collection company, since it is not the original creditor must comply with the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, or FDCPA  Under the FDCPA, you can tell the collection company that you would like written verification of the debt, by mailing in or calling in a dispute to the claim.  You have a legal right to dispute the debt at this stage of the collection process for any reason.  While the debt is in dispute status, the collection firm cannot continue to contact you.   This includes a law firm or an attorney, who is also classified under FDCPA as a third party collector subject to the terms of the FDCPA.    If you inform the collection firm that you are represented by an attorney, the collector must direct all future correspondence to the attorney who represents you.   You can also inform the collector that they may not contact you.   Violations of the FDCPA can result in a $1,000.00 liquidated damages award for each violation, plus attorney fees.  

When a creditor is not able to pressure the debtor to pay on an account, this usually results in the account being sent to a collection attorney or law firm. Sometimes, the debt is sold off by the creditor to investors who purchase the right to collect the debt ( plus all contractual interest on the account per the original contract).  Sometimes large collection law firms purchase these debts and move forward on collection.  The last stage of collection is legal action.  Legal action involves the collection law firm filing a complaint.   If the claim does not qualify as a small claims complaint  ( generally a claim under $3,000.00), the creditor must be represented by an attorney to sue the debtor.   

When defending a creditor lawsuit in Alabama, the debtor or his or her attorney should first make sure that the creditor has properly served the debtor.  Certified U.S. Mail service is not personal service if the debtor does not personally sign for the Certified Mail.  Personal service by the local county Sheriff's office or a licensed process server will be effective service if they file a sworn statement indicating that the debtor did in fact receive service of the Complaint.  Next, the debtor should examine the complaint to make sure it includes a copy of the agreement upon which the debt is based upon.   In Alabama, there are statutes of limitation that prevent old or stale debts from being enforceable.  The statute of limitations can be as short as six (6) years for debts such as a credit card agreement and as long as twenty (20) years on a contract, as long as the debt was reduced to a judgment and renewed  within certain time limitations.  

The Debtor should check all signatures on the contract.   In cases where a debt has been sold to a third party debt buyer firm, it is often the case that the transfer declaration form does not properly reference the contract upon which the lawsuit has been based, The Debtor should always file a request for production of documents and request a copy of all documents in the possession of the creditor related to the account, and all documents to be presented at the trial of the case.  Without proof of the debtor's liability, usually the debtor's valid signature, the debt cannot be enforced under basic contract law.   The debt may be enforceable where the creditor can produce records such as cancelled checks from the debtor as payment on the account, or phone records, computer records or bank records showing electronic payments on the account.   The creditor will also present regular billing statements  to show an ongoing history on the account, all under a theory of law called "quantum meruit" or "unjust enrichment.   A creditor will be unable to establish in most cases where there is no signed agreement the interest rate which should be applied to the principle amount due, and therefore the debtor is usually justified in starting settlement negotiations at a figure which does not include the interest which cannot be proven with a written, signed agreement.  

In most cases of an unsecured claim, the debtor can file for protection under the U.S. Bankruptcy Code to obtain a discharge of the debt.  It is important to consult with an attorney who is experienced in bankruptcy matters to determine the best option in your particular case.  

About the Author

Kevin Ryan

"I'll never be the kind of attorney your creditors want me to be. I'll always be the kind of attorney you NEED me to be. Call me. I'll BE there for you. And I'll make them go away."  -Kevin Ryan, Attorney at Law Kevin Ryan is a graduate of the College of Wooster and the Cleveland Marshall College of Law. He is admitted to practice before all Alabama State Courts, the United States District Court for the Southern District of Alabama, and the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Alabama. The United States Bankruptcy Court is a part of the United States District Court. Since 1998, Mr. Ryan has represented thousands of individual clients in bankruptcy, criminal, divorce, probate, personal injury, and real estate matters.  Attorney Ryan is also a licensed real estate agent in Alabama.  He handles  Bank-owned properties, short sales, and conventional sales in addition to conventional real estate listings.   This wide range of experience enables Attorney Ryan to take a wider look at your legal matter. It is important to consult with an attorney who can see from experience how other legal issues may affect your situation, and advise you accordingly. Personal Info Kevin Ryan is a member of First Baptist Church in Silverhill, Alabama. He resides in Silverhill with his wife Jessica and their three children. Committed to helping our Clients achieve a fresh financial start Our practice focuses primarily on consumer bankruptcy matters under Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 of the United States Bankruptcy Code.  Our law practice also includes matters where bankruptcy litigation, appellate work, or involvement in civil lawsuits is needed by a client.     No representation is made that the quality of any of these legal services is of higher quality than another attorney or law firm.   The United States Bankruptcy Code requires the following notice:  We are a Debt Relief Agency, which means we help people get legal relief from their Debts through the bankruptcy process. Interested in learning more about our bankruptcy attorney near Mobile, Alabama? Contact Us for help with chapter 7 bankruptcy or chapter 13 bankruptcy in Mobile, Baldwin and Washington counties. Education Juris Doctor, Cleveland Marshall College of Law, 1997 Employed full time as a paralegal while attending law school in the evenings. B.A., The College of Wooster, 1994 NCAA Div.III All Conference (N.C.A.C.) Football Team : Defense 1993; Most Inspirational Senior Award 1993; Co-captain 1993; Letterman 1991-1993; Phi Sigma Alapha Fraternity 1991-1994; Athletic Director Jurisdictions Admitted to Practice Alabama


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment


We serve the following localities: Choctaw county, Washington county, Clarke county, Monroe county, Escambia county, Mobile County including Eight Mile, Grand Bay, Irvington, Mobile, Prichard, Saraland, Semmes, Theodore, and Tillmans Corner; and Baldwin County including Bay Minette, Daphne, Fairhope, Foley, and Robertsdale.

I'll BE there for you.

I'll never be the kind of attorney your creditors want me to be. I'll always be the kind of attorney you NEED me to be. Call me. I'll BE there for you. - Kevin Ryan, Attorney at Law