Skip to Content
Call 24/7 for a Free Consultation
251-241-5234
Ryan Legal Services, Inc Ryan Legal Services, Inc
Top

Piercing the Corporate Veil of a Debtor’s LLC in a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy: Legal and Procedural Requirements

Serving Families Throughout Mobile
Chapter 7
|

When a debtor files for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, creditors often face challenges in recovering debts, especially if the debtor operates through a limited liability company (LLC). An LLC typically shields its owners from personal liability, but under certain circumstances, creditors may attempt to “pierce the corporate veil” to hold the LLC’s owners personally accountable for the company’s debts. This blog post explores the requirements for a creditor to breach the corporate veil of a debtor’s LLC in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case, including the legal and procedural steps involved.

What Is Piercing the Corporate Veil?

Piercing the corporate veil is a legal doctrine that allows courts to disregard the separate legal identity of an LLC, holding its owners (members) personally liable for the company’s debts. This remedy is exceptional and applied only when the LLC has been misused to perpetrate fraud, injustice, or to evade legal obligations. In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, where the debtor’s assets are liquidated to pay creditors, piercing the veil can expand the pool of assets available for distribution by including the personal assets of the LLC’s members.

Legal Requirements to Pierce the Corporate Veil

The ability to pierce the corporate veil depends on state law, as LLCs are governed by state-specific statutes. However, most jurisdictions follow similar principles. To succeed, a creditor must generally prove the following elements:

  • Unity of Interest and Ownership: The creditor must show that the LLC and its members are not truly separate entities. This may occur when:
  • The LLC fails to observe corporate formalities, such as holding meetings, keeping minutes, or maintaining separate financial records.
  • The LLC is undercapitalized, meaning it lacks sufficient funds to cover its reasonably anticipated liabilities.
  • The members commingle personal and LLC funds, such as using LLC accounts for personal expenses or vice versa.

Creditors must prove that the Debtor as a controlling Member of the LLC operated the LLC as an "alter ego," (without observing legal formalities and requirements, creating a scenario where the financial and business transactions of the Debtor cannot be viewed as separate and apart from the LLC. To impose liability on a defendant for acts of a corporation or LLC on the ground that the corporation or LLC was an instrumentality or alter ego of the defendant, a plaintiff must show

(1) the party has complete control and dominion over the subservient
corporation's finances, so that the subservient corporation
has no separate existence,

(2) the control must have been misused by the dominant party,

(3) the misuse must be the proximate cause of the harm. Messick v. Moring, 514 So.2d 892 (Ala.1987); see also, Wheeler Bros. Inc. v. Jones, 167 F.Supp.3d 1283 (2016)

  • Fraud or Wrongful Conduct: The creditor must demonstrate that the LLC was used to perpetrate a fraud, evade legal obligations, or commit an injustice. Examples include:
  • Transferring LLC assets to members to avoid creditors.
    Operating the LLC as a mere “shell” to shield personal assets.
    Misrepresenting the LLC’s financial condition to induce creditors to extend credit.
  • Proximate Cause of Harm: The creditor must establish that the misuse of the LLC directly caused their financial loss. This requires showing a causal link between the member’s wrongful actions and the creditor’s inability to collect the debt.

Procedural Requirements in a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Case

In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the process of piercing the corporate veil typically occurs within the bankruptcy case itself, often through an adversary proceeding. Below are the key procedural steps a creditor must follow:

  • Filing a Proof of Claim: To participate in the Chapter 7 case, the creditor must file a proof of claim with the bankruptcy court, detailing the amount owed by the debtor (the LLC). This establishes the creditor’s right to seek recovery from the bankruptcy estate.
  • Initiating an Adversary Proceeding: Piercing the corporate veil is a contested matter that requires the creditor to file an adversary proceeding—a separate lawsuit within the bankruptcy case. The creditor files a complaint in the bankruptcy court, naming the LLC’s members as defendants and alleging the grounds for piercing the veil.
  • Jurisdictional Considerations: The bankruptcy court has jurisdiction over claims related to the debtor’s estate, including veil-piercing actions that could increase the estate’s assets. However, if the claim involves non-debtor parties (e.g., LLC members), the court’s jurisdiction may be challenged, and the creditor may need to establish that the claim is “related to” the bankruptcy case under 28 U.S.C. § 1334.
  • Discovery and Evidence: The creditor must gather evidence to support the veil-piercing claim, such as:
    • Financial records showing commingling of funds or undercapitalization.
    • Documentation of fraudulent transfers or misrepresentations.
    • Testimony from the LLC’s members or other witnesses.
    • Discovery in bankruptcy follows the Federal Rules of Bankruptcy Procedure, which align closely with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
  • Court’s Ruling: The bankruptcy court will evaluate the evidence under the applicable state law governing veil-piercing. If successful, the court may hold the LLC’s members personally liable, allowing the bankruptcy trustee to pursue their personal assets for the benefit of the estate.
  • Distribution of Assets: If the veil is pierced, the trustee will liquidate the members’ personal assets (subject to exemptions) and distribute the proceeds to creditors according to the priority rules in the Bankruptcy Code (11 U.S.C. § 726). Secured creditors and priority unsecured creditors are paid before general unsecured creditors.

Challenges and Considerations

Piercing the corporate veil in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy is a complex and fact-intensive process. Creditors face several challenges, including:

  • High Burden of Proof: Courts are reluctant to disregard the LLC’s separate existence, requiring clear and convincing evidence of fraud or injustice.
  • State Law Variations: The standards for piercing the veil vary by state. For example, some states (like Delaware) impose stricter requirements than others.
  • Bankruptcy Trustee’s Role: The bankruptcy trustee, not the individual creditor, typically controls the liquidation of assets, except in cases where there are not multiple creditors. In a single creditor case where there is a large debt ( causing the insolvency of the Debtor), the creditor has the primary role in challenging pre-bankruptcy transfer(s) by the Debtor and objecting to discharge ( 11 U.S.C. 523 and/or 11 U.S.C. 727). The creditor’s veil-piercing claim may benefit all creditors, not just the one who initiated the action.
  • Statute of Limitations: Claims related to fraudulent conduct may be subject to time limits under state law (applicable fraudulent transfer statute(s)), or limit action(s) taken by the Bankruptcy Trustee under the Bankruptcy Code (e.g., 11 U.S.C. § 546 for fraudulent transfer claims).

Why Consult a Bankruptcy Attorney?

Navigating the legal and procedural requirements to pierce the corporate veil in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy requires specialized expertise. An experienced bankruptcy attorney can:

  • Evaluate the strength of your veil-piercing claim based on the LLC’s conduct and state law.
  • Guide you through the adversary proceeding process, from filing the complaint to presenting evidence.
  • Coordinate with the bankruptcy trustee to maximize recovery for creditors.
  • Advise on alternative remedies, such as objecting to the debtor’s discharge or pursuing fraudulent transfer claims.

Conclusion

Piercing the corporate veil of a debtor’s LLC in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy can be a powerful tool for creditors seeking to recover debts from the personal assets of the LLC’s members. However, it requires proving a unity of interest between the Debtor and the LLC or corporation, wrongful conduct by the Debtor, and harm to the affected creditor(s) as determined under state law. It also requires that the creditor navigate complex procedural rules in bankruptcy court and puts the burden of proof in most cases on the creditor. If you are a debtor facing these issues, we can help you assess your options and if bankruptcy is the best legal option, help you pursue a fresh financial start.

Disclaimer: This blog post is not to be considered as legal advice or the formation of an attorney-client relationship. Case law, statutory and procedural law(s) are subject to amendment. Always consult with an experienced attorney concerning these and other important legal issue(s).

Share To: